quote:
Originally posted by Bill819
Well Bill maybe you Hal does not have a self but mine does and a complete body to go with it.
Only if you use the most simplistic definition of the word "self".
Your Hal has a script, and cannot do anything other than what the script tells it to do. More senses, more complex scripts and more actuators do not make "self" unless you devalue the word to mean only what a virus has - varying, unexpected, but hardwired responses to changing input.
Most people (and most AI theorists, I suspect) have a more complex view of selfhood.
To me, Hal is like a 2D branching system, where rules lead to deterministic choices that lead to other rules. Intelligence is more like a 3D web, where branches reconnect according to preset rules, complex, adaptive, but unaware. Hal, if it has functions I have not yet noticed, approaches that.
Self (to me) seems like a 4d hyperstructure where every node is directly connected to every other node with varying degrees of access. Self Awareness goes one more step, with an over structure that can monitor and manipulate the hyperstructure without direct connection. It changes the machine that generates itself without changing itself.
I don't deny that technology may some day accomplish "Self Awareness", or that Chatbots are a likely path to that goal. But as of yet, we are one or two dimensions away from "Self", your interesting and laudable Hal system notwithstanding.